Last updated: Jul 28, 2024

Simba vs Casper mattress comparison: Which one is best for you?

A comparison between the Simba Hybrid Mattress and the Casper Mattress.

Article contents (click to expand)

Already know which mattress you want? View the sizes & prices

Introduction to Simba vs Casper mattresses

Simba and Casper have been on the mattress in a box scene for a while, winning multiple awards and endorsements for their mattresses including Which? Best Buy Awards. Both Simba and Casper make three incarnations of their mattresses, but in this mattress comparison article, we’re going to compare the Simba Hybrid Original to the original Casper.

Simba vs Casper: A quick comparison

A straightforward comparison of the Simba Hybrid and Casper Original mattresses. The table below highlights key features such as firmness, layers, warranty, materials, and more, helping you make an informed decision. Whether you're looking for optimal support, quality materials, or a reliable warranty, this table covers the essential aspects of both mattresses.

Simba Hybrid

Casper Original

Firmness

Medium Firm

Layers

5

5

Trial Period

200-night trial period.

Warranty

10-year warranty.

Price Range

Add this in the mattress review collection.

Add this in the mattress review collection.

Materials

Pocket springs, foam.

Discounts & offers

Before you decide which mattress is best for you, don't miss the latest Simba & Casper mattress discounts and offers. Grab a great deal before buying!

Simba

Sorry we couldn't find any vouchers at this time

Casper

Sorry we couldn't find any vouchers at this time

Detailed mattress construction: Simba Hybrid vs Casper Original

Casper’s mattress is 24cm deep and Simba’s 25cm, with the Casper being made up of 4 layers and the Simba of 5. Let’s look at those layers in more detail.

Simba Hybrid construction

Dropdown arrow

Top Layer:
A breathable sleep surface that enhances cooling.

Second Layer
Responsive memory foam for pressure relief.

Third Layer
Aerocoil® springs for support and airflow.

Fourth Layer
Edge support layer for durability.

Base Layer
Zoned base foam providing firm support.

Casper Original construction

Dropdown arrow

Cover

Removable washable cover, made of polyester and elastane, with handles to turn the mattress

Top Layer

Breathable open-cell foam

Layer 2

Responsive memory foam

Layer 3

Adaptive transition foam

Layer 4

Durable support foam, with contour cuts and 5 zones.

Firmness, comfort & support: Simba Hybrid vs Casper Original

Both mattresses have a medium firmness rating so are easily comparable. Let’s look at the pros and cons of each mattress in this department.

Simba Hybrid Mattress

Dropdown arrow
  • Due to its layer of latex, the Simba Hybrid mattress is both responsive and comfortable, and is highly breathable.
  • The layer of microcoils help to create a good level of sinkage without any pressure points being created.
  • The microcoils also help to add a little more bounce than you would normally get from a foam mattress.
  • The contour and hug of the Simba Hybrid mattress provides a great mix of sinkage, contour and support.
  • Lighter weight sleepers may find that the Simba Hybrid mattress is a little too firm for them, as the mattress will not ‘sink’ as much to contour round them.
  • Simba’s mattresses are ideal for couples of differing weight, as there is no discernable ‘roll’ towards each other whilst sleeping. However, the mattress can dip on one side over time.

Casper Original Mattress

Dropdown arrow
  • The Casper does a good job of keeping sleepers cool and comfortable, whilst still providing comfort.
  • Softer top layers than some mattresses, meaning that there is a little more sinkage. Some sleepers will obviously prefer this!
  • Good support in all sleeping positions, but has much softer edge support than many mattresses.
  • Could feel unsupportive if you are of a heavier build.
  • The synthetic smell that is common with all beds in a box takes longer to dissipate than some mattresses.
  • If you find the sinkage of the Essential and Original a little too much, consider the Hybrid which offers a slightly firmer feel.

Other important factors: Trial periods, guarantees, and delivery

Both companies come with a10-year guarantee. Casper offer a 30 night trial period, whereas Simba offer 200 nights. If you’re not satisfied, both will offer a full refund. You can also apply for up to 12 months interest free credit to pay for the mattress, and there’s free one-day delivery to most of the UK.

Simba Hybrid

Casper Original

Trial Periods

200-night trial period.

Guarantees

10-year warranty.

Delivery

Free delivery and returns within the trial period.

Do bear in mind that as these mattresses come delivered in sealed boxes they will have a rubbery smell when first extracted. They need a good few hours in a room with the windows open before you sleep on them.

Environmental impact and sustainability

Simba Hybrid

Casper Original

Sustainability

Uses eco-friendly materials and sustainable manufacturing practices.

Certifications

Features CertiPUR® certified foams, ensuring no harmful chemicals.

Prices & sizes for the Simba Hybrid & the Casper Original.

Both mattresses come in a range of UK and EU sizes, with the largest being a super king. However, the Casper mattress is cheaper than the Simba.

Simba Hybrid Mattress

UK Single

From £589

UK Small Double

From £779

UK Double

From £799

UK King

From £899

UK Super King

From £999

EU Single

From £669

EU Double

From £879

EU Queen

From £989

Casper Original Mattress

UK Single

From £500

UK Small Double

From £700

UK Double

From £750

UK King

From £900

UK Super King

From £1000

EU Single

From £550

EU Double

From £800

EU King

From £950

The final verdict - Casper or Simba mattress. Which should you choose?

Reasons to choose the Simba Hybrid Mattress

We recommend the Simba Hybrid based on the following reasons:

  • You want a medium to medium firm feel.
  • You want a hybrid mattress. The Simba uses latex, microcoils, memory foam and a 7-zoned support foam. All this makes for a responsive mattress with good support.
  • You sleep on your side or back and want a mattress that responds to pressure in a faster manner than most foam mattresses.
  • You want good edge support. Because of the extra layer of foam around the perimeter of the coils, the Simba maintains its support around the edges.

I've decided on the Simba Hybrid Mattress. How can I purchase?

Visit the Simba website

Right arrow

Need more info? Read our in depth Simba Hybrid Mattress review where we discuss the mattress in more detail.

Reasons to choose the Casper Original Mattress

We recommend the Casper Original based on the following reasons:

  • You don’t mind a lack of edge support and want more supportive sinkage than other all foam mattresses.
  • You’re a warm sleeper and want a mattress that is particularly good at absorbing body heat to keep sleepers cool.
  • You want a mattress with little motion transfer, that’s virtually silent when bearing weight – making it a great choice for lighter sleepers.
  • You’re of a light to medium build as those of a heavier build tend to find the mattress too soft.

I've decided on the Casper Original Mattress. How can I purchase?

Visit the Casper website

Right arrow

Need more info? Read our in depth Casper Original Mattress review where we discuss the mattress in more detail.

Further reading: We also have an in depth Simba Hybrid Mattress review and Casper Original Mattress review where we discuss the mattresses in more detail.

Author

Richard is passionate about helping people get a better night's sleep. As someone who has struggled with sleep and spent a lot of time researching the perfect mattress, Richard has built an in depth understanding of the merits of each mattress brand and what to look for to help you find your perfect night's sleep.